I will introduce a term reduction iepresentation of the calculus of indication in. Spencerbrowns laws of form 16 and at extensions of this work for multiple valued logic due to myself and francisco varela, 17. An esoteric guide to spencer browns laws of form seth t. You can find out about a little of the content here but after this rereading i think im now ready for the final verdict. Hopefully the evident hostility of the previous answers made you take pause. It traces how a single distinction in a void leads to the creation of space, where.
Spencerbrown a deep debt of gratitude, because without some of the calculus of indications theorems and innovative applications to logic published in his groundbreaking book, laws of form. Browns writing style is so obscure that it has more the flavor of a religious text rather than a. The paper discusses key reentry forms that include the fibonacci form. Spencer browns paradigmatic work with the laws of form and gregory batesons epistemological tools of punctuation, logical typing and double description. The key feature of this symbol is that it makes a distinction between an inside and an outside so we can replace it with. Laws of form pdf fill online, printable, fillable, blank. Laws of form an exploration in mathematics and foundations. Spencer browns 1969 work laws of form is a pivot, a reference, and a place from which to make excursions into both. A first result of a translation of the lof into the framework of the cl shows the definability of the lof initial order by the initials number and.
Spencerbrowns laws of form is a rather obscure book with perhaps an unusual viewpoint. The representations themselves are not inherited, only the forms. Spencerbrown proposes the mark of distinction archetypally distinguishing inside from outside as a definition of maximal contrast. Nathaniel hellerstein, with recourse to spencerbrowns laws of form, developed a socalled diamond logic hellerstein 1997, a nonaristotelian logic in which the classical truth values of true and false are supplemented with the two values of true, but false and false, but true which oscillate with a unit delay.
It has attracted the attention of people who have absorbed all the typical flotsam and jetsam of several disciplines and still find something left to be desired. Thus we cannot escape the fact that the world we know is constructed in order and thus in such a. He describes himself as a mathematician, consulting engineer, psychologist, educational consultant and practitioner, consulting psychotherapist, author, and poet. Browns laws of form 1969 reveals a new calculus of mathematics, rfa introduces a new way of tracking how distinctions and frames.
George spencer browns vita george spencerbrown worked with bertrand russell in foundations of mathematics from 1960 onwards. Spencerbrown the g is for george made a remarkable attempt to deal with this question with the publication of laws of form in 1969. Spencerbrown the g is for george made a remarkable attempt to. Following spencer brown, one can describe the recursive form of. Spencer browns 1969 work laws of form is a pivot, a reference, and a place from which to make excursions into both simplicity and complexity. Twelve years after writing those words, george spencerbrown published a great metaphysics. Laws of form is a book published by g spencer brown, i think in around 1972. Laws of form is underappreciated because it requires a rather strenuous, sustained effort on the part of the reader, or, in spencer browns words. Having reached this point literally we are still on page 1. Spencer browns book laws of form informally presents three distinct logical systems. An initial discussion of epistemology includes a specification of g. We take as given the idea of distinction and the idea of indication, and that one cannot make an indication without drawing a.
Laws of form is an approach to mathema tics, and to epistemo logy, that begins and ends with the notion of a distinction. Rereading it now forty years on i find its elegance and power in no way diminished. Let george spencer brown gsb, a logician, engineer, and teacher, wrote a curious little book called laws of form, that inspired countless interesting people of widely varying backgrounds. He worked with j d boyd in experiments in the special senses, and with d t harris in the medical uses of hypnosis. This sketch takes a first step to analyze the laws of form fol in the context of combinatory logic cl. Changing consciousness one evening in the fall of 1969, along the picturesque cliffs of big sur, california, media gadfly and whole earth catalog editor, stewart brand, approached the neuro. The purpose of this chapter is to explore the idea of a sign, using g. Spencer browns laws of form, rfa offers both researchers and practitioners of all kinds a formal way of tracking the dramatological construction and movement of a conversation through its beginning.
He worked with ludwig wittgenstein in the foundations of philosophy in 195051. The paper begins with a new characterization of the infinite decomposition of a rectangle into squares that is characteristic of the golden rectangle. Laws of form is an approach to mathematics, and to epistemology, that. Spencerbrowns laws of form lof, sb and its ramifications. Alfred north whitehead alonzo church already appear argument arrangement axiom boole boolean algebra boundary calculus of indications called cancellation canon chapter circle circumference condensation connexion consequence consider constant constructed cross r. Monotonelight factorization for kan fibrations of simplicial sets with respect to groupoids chikhladze, dimitri, homology, homotopy and applications, 2004. Mathematicians have shown that all of formal logic can be derived from g. Pdf iconoclastic thoughts on spencer browns laws of form. A formal theory of the calculus of indication core. Spencerbrown s laws of form is summarized and the philosophical implications examined.
In following a postclassical approach and some reference to system theory by niklas luhmann as well as the works on autonomous systems by francisco varela. This work is a condensation of part of the authors doctoral dissertation in systems science, fuzzy reasoning, logics of selfreference, and the use of nonclassical logics in systems modeling, which is currently in progress. With laws of form 1969, george spencerbrown presented a calculus of indication that can partly be viewed as axiomatization of the structure of boolean algebras. I present a proof of the completeness of varelas calculus for selfreference denoted csr. Spencerbrowns laws of form cybernetic version of article. On rational limits of shelahspencer graphs brody, justin and laskowski, m. Spencerbrown, published in 1969, that straddles the boundary between mathematics and philosophy. Spencerbrowns laws of form, which has a formalism of great simplicity for the act of distinguishing and its basic laws. The book can be read as an important and troublesome work of logic and mathematics. I first read laws of form whilst at aston university in 1970. George spencerbrown died in wiltshire, england, on august 25, 2016, at the age of 93. Departing from george spencer browns laws of form and the works of german sociologist dirk baecker, a formal model of the firm in the postgrowth economy is developed. He is the parteditor of material for russells autobiography.
Restricted recursive arithmetic was introduced by church in 1955 as. Laws of mathematics and logic describe the nature of rational thought and inference kants transcendental idealism, and differently g. Laws of form an exploration in mathematics and foundations rough draft by louis h. In addition to the conciseness that browns laws of form provide. Gsb himself seemed to understand the importance of the laws of form, even if there were some of these more subtle specifics which were not apparent to him or at least which he did not explicitly recognize.
For example, physical laws such as the law of gravity or scientific laws attempt to describe the fundamental nature of the universe itself. The qualitative report books the qualitative report. Rate of escape of random walks on wreath products and related groups revelle, david, annals of probability, 2003. The first section of the present thesis deals with the content of this calculus of indications and thus can be regarded in the paradigm of mathematics as structure. Spencer browns laws of form is summarized and the philosophical implications examined. These are some simple first impressions of spencer browns book laws of form1. He showed how the mere act of making a distinction creates space, then developed two laws that emerge ineluctably from the creation of space. Spencerbrowns work laws of form, was precisely a determination of the a priori laws governing human thought before any.
Spencer browns laws of form the archetype itself is empty and purely formal, nothing but a facultas praeformandi, a possibility of representation which is given a priori. Few books have literally taken my breath away but this one did. The third system is interpreted here through alonzo churchs restricted recursive arithmetic. Spencer brown probability and scientific inference, london. I mentioned this book a year ago but at that time i was talking from memory and from second hand descriptions. Abstract this essay is an exploration of the question what reflections might result from shining an esotericspiritual light upon george spencer browns book, laws of form. Rooted to gregory batesons notion of contextual frame and the way that a distinction can recursively operate on itself as formulated by g. The first two chapters present a base for understanding the meaning of cybernetic epistemology. The addition of the riemans hypothesis proof adds to the power of the book. An illustration of a computer application window wayback machine an illustration of an open book. Laws of form is a mathematical system which deals with the emergence of anything out of the void. Spencerbrowns interest in paradoxes, the only sentence that makes a statement that something is, is the statement, which says no such statements are used in this book. George spencer brown in his spirit, i would like to say.
1328 106 1191 1284 1195 364 884 1064 1437 377 1270 653 1324 901 580 978 1227 1247 847 772 631 1161 958 1493 158 697 832 1487 1521 1156 518 880 457 1111 41 892 442 265 1157 202 1129